Subscribe to feed via email:
Subscribe RSS

Archive for the Category "Contests"

Industry Insider Screenwriting Contest – Reader Submission Nov 05

Disgruntled

A few months back, a reader of my blog (Danny), posted a comment on one of my articles about the Industry Insider Screenwriting Contest. He was “disgruntled” and more than a little baffled as to why his 15 page script didn’t make the cut — especially when he felt he was just “an inch away from opportunity.”

Seeing a chance for fans of my blog to learn from his experience, I got in touch with Danny and promised to take a look at his submission, if he allowed me to post my critique publicly on my site. I’ve been busy for the last couple of months, but finally had some free time this week, so I dove in.

While I can’t speak to the exact reasons the contest judges chose not to select Danny’s entry as one of the finalists, I can certainly offer my opinion based on my years of experience as a script consultant.

First Impressions

Question: Typically, how many pages does it take for an experienced script reader to rule out your script as a prospective contest winner?

Answer: One.

Yup, one page.

Why? Because most scripts are really poorly written — right from the get-go. If the writing is bad on page one, it rarely gets better by page 10. After all, if you’re going to make any single page in your script shine more than the others, it should be page one. That’s the critical page. That’s the page that solidifies the readers’ first impressions.

But first impressions begin with the title page itself. In Danny’s script, there were three things I highlighted on the title page alone. That’s a huge red flag.

Danny's Title Page

(Click to Enlarge)

Do you see the issues?

  1. Danny put the genre next to the title. That’s highly non-standard.
  2. The “Based on” sentence has an awkward construction. It’s not even necessary to put this line on the title page.
  3. The title page is not the place for links to social media pages. Just provide the contact information. That means an email address and maybe your phone number.

So we haven’t even gotten to the first page of the script and there are 3 issues. Not a good sign.

But what does the first page look like? I think the best way to illustrate this is to show you a different one first.

This is the first page of the script that ended up winning the contest for that cycle, written by J.R. Phillips. Like I did, you can download it here. Her script is entitled: THE BADLANDS: DEAD GIRLS DON’T CRY. (By the way, her title page was clean and flawless.)

BADLANDS: DEAD GIRLS DON'T CRY (First Page)

(Click to Enlarge)
First page of J.R. Phillips’ Industry Insider Screenwriting Contest winning script BADLANDS: DEAD GIRLS DON’T CRY

Impressive. Only one technical issue! ONE! And even then it’s nitpicking.

The “rule” is that if you’re going to capitalize sounds then you should capitalize the sound AND the thing that makes the sound (i.e. “The WOODEN FURNITURE CREAKS”). Again this is a minor peccadillo on an otherwise brilliantly executed first page. It certainly isn’t anything that distracts from the quality of the writing or the story itself. And this “rule” is violated all the time in professional scripts these days.

Now let’s look at Danny’s first page…

Danny's First Page

(Click to Enlarge)
Danny’s First Page from his script entitled FIONA

Yikes! See the difference?

I annotated this script, like I do with my script notes service, and it’s riddled with problems. I’ve written fifteen different notes for dozens of issues — all on page one.

Let’s take a look from top to bottom:

  1. If you’re going to use “FADE IN:” it should be left justified. Bonus marks: Only use one line space underneath. Not two.
  2. For the SUPERIMPOSE line — the use of single and double quotes is odd. I get that he wants the line to appear in quotes, but it’s better to just  show what you want to appear.
  3. Why doesn’t the Matthew 13.10-16 reference wrap around normally onto the next line?
  4. “OVER BLACK:” — Aren’t we over black at the outset? What does the superimposed text appear over?
  5. “EXT.  UGSTON” — Be consistent with your spacing. One space is preferable after “EXT.”, but if you’re going to use two spaces, then make sure you do that throughout your script.
  6. Scene heading modifiers like DAWN, DUSK, MORNING, etc. are rarely a good idea to include in your script. Try to stick with DAY and NIGHT. The audience doesn’t get to see the word “DAWN.” They interpret the time of day by what they see in the scene. So based on what you describe in the scene, we’ll know it’s dawn — not in the scene heading.
  7. What’s up with all the unusual capitalization? It makes for a jarring, peculiar read.
  8. ” ‘Giant Jets of Water’ ” — why is this phrase (and others) in quotes?
  9. “Sharp Rock and massive Boulders…” — Formatting issue. He’s missing a line space here… Or he’s accidentally hit enter.
  10. Be wary of underlining too many things in your script. Underlines should be used sparingly for very important elements that you need to highlight. Use underlining too much and it loses its impact (and brands you as an amateur). Note: Underlining scene headings is an entirely different issue — and it works.
  11. Whenever I see writers use slash and two descriptors (e.g. “Bank/Mound”), I think that they couldn’t make up their mind as to which one to use. If both are necessary, use a comma.
  12. Third paragraph from the bottom — isn’t Fiona already at the edge? How can she heave herself at something she’s already at? Perhaps he means that she tries to climb onto the bank and slips or something? Also — “heaves herself out” could imply that she’s pushing away from the bank. If this expression is to be used, I think it needs to be qualified as “… heaves herself out of the water.”
  13. Same paragraph… It’s eight lines long! It’s not technically a mistake, but it’s a big red flag. Typically, 3 or 4 lines max — especially for scene description in an action sequence.
  14. “Drape” and “draped.” It’s best not to use the same word in such close proximity. Same with “heaves” and “mangled” for that matter. Variety is the spice of life… and of good writing.

It came as no surprise to me that things did not improve on pages 2 through 15.

What About the Story Itself?

It doesn’t matter.

Again, I can’t speak for the Industry Insider Screenwriting Contest judges, but here’s the thing… Even if the underlying story is fantastic, there’s no way I could present this as an example of finalist-quality writing. It is, after all, a writing contest. Having a good story is only one piece of the puzzle. Great writers can:

  1. come up with a compelling story
  2. write it well
  3. demonstrate a command of the rules particular to screenwriting.

One out of three isn’t going to cut it, especially when there are thousands of entries to choose from.

The truth is, even beyond all of the technical mistakes, the writing isn’t very strong. I only mentioned a few things that stuck out. If I were editing this first page, there would have been many more notes.

Danny seems like a friendly, eager screenwriter, and I wish him all the best. In time, he may be able to better his writing to the point where he starts to place in contests, etc. But he’s not there yet.

The first thing I would recommend to him, and frankly any screenwriter out there, is to read and absorb a screenplay formatting book like David Trottier’s The Screenwriter’s Bible, or  Christopher Riley’s The Hollywood Standard.

Proper script formatting won’t make your story any better, but it will let your writing stand on its own merits. And that’s all you can hope for.

Any other issues with Danny’s script that bear mentioning? Who can tell me why his main character introduction doesn’t work?

Screenplay Competitions Insight Jun 13

Screenplay Competitions

Screenwriting TrophyAt the Great American PitchFest 2012, I attended four free classes. In my last post, I discussed the class that dealt with selling your script. Today’s post gives you the deets on screenwriting contests, courtesy of the following panel:

The free class was called: “Screenplay Competitions – How to Win, Why Enter & How They Can Change Your Life”

That sounded like a something I needed to check out! Here are some of the things I learned:

  • Each of the top competitions receive anywhere from 5,000 to 7,000+ scripts (The Nicholl receives the most). CineStory receives only about 600 scripts (so the chances of winning are greater).
  • For the Nicholl competition, even the quarterfinalists will get contacted by producers, managers, etc.
  • It’s a misconception that companies are getting rich off of holding screenwriting competitions. Everyone on the panel genuinely scoffed at that idea.
  • A common script concept this year has been: “Senior citizens on the run.”
  • A common story conceit has been an opening where a young woman is staggering through the woods, then we flash back to how she got there (or it ends up being a dream).
  • If you want to see how screenwriting contests stack up, head over to MovieBytes.com. The site features user-submitted reviews and ratings for each competition.

The question and answer period was especially enlightening. Here are some good ones (all paraphrased):

Q. Is it a good idea to resubmit the same script two years in a row?

A. If it’s been substantially rewritten, then yes. If it hasn’t been rewritten, the answer was mixed. Most judges seemed to think that it was a bad idea to resubmit the same script, however Joan Wai related a story about a writer who submitted the exact same script a second year in a row and ended up winning a Nicholl fellowship!

It was also noted that quite often competitions will have about 50% new judges from year to year, so it may pay to resubmit if you feel that your script was misunderstood. Until robots get into the game, judging will continue to be subjective. But the bottom line is that everyone’s looking for a great script.

Q. Has the advent of screenwriting software improved the quality of  scripts over the years?

A. “They’re just as bad, but better written.” – Howard Casner

Note: He said it jokingly, but there was truth behind it. Of all the panelists, his passion for finding innovative scripts and quality writing was probably the most evident.

Q. What’s the percentage of scripts that are good?

A. The general consensus seemed to be about 1 in 20. (Note: At the previous panel discussion of script consultants, they said about 1 in 100. Perhaps the quality of writing is better for competitions than it is in general.)

Q. Is there an advantage to submitting your script earlier versus later in the competition cycle?

A. Obviously it’s cheaper if you submit your script earlier, but most seemed to think there was no real advantage. However, one judge admitted that they tend to get tougher on scripts as the competition goes on. But that is balanced out by the fact that later in the competition, a really good script might be fresher in their minds when it comes time to fight over the finalists.

They also agreed that it’s probably not such a great idea to submit your script right at the very last possible minute. It’ll still get read fairly in their contests, but in less reputable contests, it may not get read with as much vigor or interest.

What are your thoughts on screenwriting contests? Any success stories out there?

Category: Contests  | 2 Comments
Congratulations to Chris Bullett! Dec 29

Gideon's LawMy buddy Chris Bullett just won the November 2011 Best Script Award in the Amazon Studios contest!!! What a great way to surge into 2012.

His $20,000 winning script is called Gideon’s Law. Here’s the logline for this Thriller/Action-Adventure:

A disgraced young cop is assigned a routine civilian ride-along and quickly learns that his passenger is not what he seems and he has just entered into a brutal battle with a killer who will stop at nothing to achieve his goal.

I’ve had the privilege of reading and critiquing a number of Chris’s scripts, and I can say with confidence that he has a bright career ahead of him. (Actually, he has a pretty bright career right now!)

Congratulations!


Category: Contests  | 3 Comments
Industry Insider Contest Scripts Available Aug 02

Industry Insider Screenwriting ContestA while back I discussed my experience with the first Writers Store’s Industry Insider Screenwriting Contest. Even though my submission wasn’t what they were looking for, I was still very impressed with the contest itself and the opportunity.

However, if you’re like me, I’m sure you’d like to see how your 15 pages compared to the ones that made the top ten. Well now you can! The Writers Store has just posted nine of them.

To see them all (including the winner’s pages) for the Simon Kinberg contest logline, please click here.

UPDATE: For those entering the current round of the Industry Insider Screenwriting contest, here’s a great tip from Dana Hahn, Industry Insider Contest Coordinator, who was kind enough to provide it to me:

“The main thing that we’re looking for in our contest is the quality of the writing, and a unique take on the logline.”
- Dana Hahn, Industry Insider Contest Coordinator

Thanks Dana! And good luck everyone!


Professional script critique, logline and page notes for $59.
(Yup, the rumors are true. It’s the best frikken deal on the web.)
Vote for your favorite in the Cyberspace Open Jul 12

CyberSpace Open - Cast VoteThe first (and last) time I entered Creative Screenwriting’s Cyberspace Open, it was a very, ahem, gut-wrenching experience.

The contest has changed a bit since 2009. There’s no more 24 hour phase or two hour rush final. They also film the three finalists utilizing actors and a narrator.

I’m not a big fan of the filmed scenes. While they’re better this time around, they still smack of a high school drama class rehearsal, with most actors reading from scripts, and showing only a modest regard for the actual scene direction.

But overall the contest is a great way to test your scene-writing chops. I’m pleased to report that one of the finalists this year is Elisa Graybill from my screenwriting group. Way to go Elisa!

I genuinely think her written scene was the best, and most closely followed the scene cue. So please show Elisa some Scriptwrecked love and give her your vote if you agree with me!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...